The Hand as a criminal organization is pretty rad in Daredevil and Iron Fist, but in Defenders they suck pretty hard and are bad cannon fodder for the newly assembled team.
Sigourney Weaver – I’m not using her name in the show, because as we find out, she has many names. Outside of a scene where she subdues Elektra, she is the least scary villain we’ve seen in the Hell’s Kitchen MCU. It is a waste of her talent, because she could have been so much more ruthless and insidious. There is no superpower or threat that backs up her authority.
The team-up — Okay, we get that Matt struggles with actually enjoying the DD life and wants nothing more than to cling to normalcy. Jessica doesn’t really play well with others. How they all end up at Midland Circle at the same time is not very well scripted except in how Jessica gets there. Danny is a little too impulsive going on his own. Murdock tailing Jessica I can kind of get behind, but Luke randomly showing up is the biggest stretch. This needed more work because it is the crucial plot point in the story.
The fingers of the Hand-
these behind-the-scenes ruthless immortals are a joke in Defenders. Bukido does not seem like he belongs in the same room. He seems like he should be a lower tier bad guy, and it’s sad that it takes Misty, Colleen, and Claire to take him out, when it really should be a Colleen Wing badassery moment.
Guy that speaks Japanese-I honestly don’t remember his name because he is so unmemorable except that he likes to speak a different language often and disembowel rare bears. Nobu was ten times better than this guy.
Madame Gao- Is the best villain in this whole group and is wasted playing second fiddle to Ripley (Sigourney). The unsanswerable seems to be how is Gao this powerful force-wielding old lady, but everyone else is just good at karate. My hope is that she survives to play behind the scenes bad guy again. Gao is the only one-even underutilized as she is-that seems like she should be leading the bad guys.
Remember the tension between her and Kingpin, the way she plays up her age and speaking a different language that she uses intermediaries and such. Gao deserved to have better characterization more loyal to her DD and Iron Fist portrayals.
Misty Knight and the NYPD precinct – Anyone else feel like sidelining all of the super friends’ friends was just asking to put them in harm’s way? Instead they were safe in the precinct. No stealthy ninjas to capture them for the end game. And Misty has a wasted role as well. There is no detective work in her role, no revelations she stumbles across. Her only function in the entire show is to ask questions and not get any answers.
To be fair, the actress did the best with what she was given, but the Misty character serves no purpose other than to wander around and get threatened with her job repeatedly. It would have been better if she could have taken a hard line with any of the superfriends, or been fired, or gone rogue. She spent 8 episodes doing nothing. That is a waste.
Karen Page-another wasted opportunity is Karen Page safe and sound as a reporter who can’t report and stowed away in the NYPD. The writers missed a golden opportunity to pit Matt’s feelings for Karen against his feelings for Elektra. She is never in danger and so there is no emotional tension for the Daredevil character. Karen also doesn’t go rogue for the story of a lifetime. She’s out on the shelf and it’s not a good place for her to be.
Trish Talk – Trish and Karen have a brief moment talking, but otherwise have their journalistic instincts thoroughly repressed and neither encounter any threat or danger. There is none of that tenacity or search for truth they have in DD and Jessica Jones. That role is given to Jessica herself who is the only curious person of the bunch.
Mister White Hat- This is the least memorable of the Hand. There is virtually no tie to the Harlem vibe we felt in Luke Cage or his potential African influence, no sense of his power, and in that regard I felt like Defenders was nearly entirely whitewashed. This is the guy that is in charge of Africa and is supposed to have some powers, but is pretty easily subdued (off camera I might add) and killed. There is no character development. At least with Gao and Bukido we have seen where they came from or at least what they do in other shows. What’s sad to me is he is never given a chance to be anything but a token black villain with a very minor role. And the white hat gimmick has no sense of mystery or threat. He casts it aside at the earliest opportunity.
Other missed opportunities:
So we’re just going to let Claire ignore that Luke has basically hooked up with half the female cast. He’s such a nice guy he’s given a pass. There’s no tension there. A perfect brief scene would be them getting it on and Luke being a little too rough and Claire getting a little banged up. Then Luke could be like, “I really like Claire, but at least I don’t have to worry about hurting Jessica physically.” No?
No tension with Matt and Claire, no tension between Jessica and Claire, no jealousy between Elektra and Karen. Colleen Wing is continually thrust into a supporting role instead of closer to the action. Also last time I looked Claire was training with Wing and had some cool hooky claw things, but we see very little action from her.
There was that scene where Jessica is talking to the architect’s wife and the grandparents are let in upstairs. This seemed like a perfect opportunity for Sigourney or another of the Hand to pretend to pay their respects and for Jessica to get into a tense staring match.